When it comes to heating your home, powering your appliances, or even fuelling your vehicle, choosing the right type of gas can make all the difference in terms of cost, efficiency, and environmental impact. In the UK, the two most popular options are Liquid Petroleum Gas (LPG) and Natural Gas.
In this post, we’ll break down the key differences between these two fuels, discussing their pros and cons, and helping you decide which is the best fit for your needs.
What Are LPG and Natural Gas?
Before we dive into comparisons, let’s define what we’re talking about.
- LPG (Liquid Petroleum Gas) is a mixture of propane and butane, stored in liquid form under pressure. It’s commonly used in areas without access to the gas grid.
- Natural Gas is mostly methane, extracted from underground gas fields, and piped directly to homes and businesses via the gas network.
Now, let’s get into the details!
1. Energy Content: Which is More Efficient?
If you’re after efficiency, you’ll want to know how much bang you get for your buck.
- LPG boasts a higher energy content at around 93 MJ per cubic metre, making it an excellent fuel for portable heating or cooking appliances.
- Natural Gas provides 38 MJ per cubic metre. While less energy-dense, it’s still highly efficient for homes connected to the gas grid.
Verdict: LPG delivers more energy per unit, but if you have access to natural gas via pipeline, it’s still a reliable, consistent energy source.
2. Storage and Distribution: Convenience is Key
How you store and access your gas can be a big factor in your decision.
- LPG is stored in tanks or cylinders, which means you’ll need space for storage and regular deliveries.
- Natural Gas is piped directly to your home or business, meaning no need for storage or regular refills.
For those living in rural or off-grid locations, LPG is often the only viable option. But for city dwellers with easy access to the gas mains, natural gas is far more convenient.
Verdict: If you live in a rural area, LPG is your best bet. In urban areas, natural gas wins for convenience.
3. Cost: Which Gas is Cheaper?
Nobody likes to pay more for energy than necessary, so let’s talk cost.
- LPG tends to be more expensive per unit due to its higher production and transportation costs.
- Natural Gas is generally cheaper, benefiting from the extensive pipeline infrastructure in the UK.
While LPG may be your only option in some regions, it’s worth noting that natural gas will typically save you money if you’re connected to the grid.
Verdict: Natural gas is the more cost-effective choice for grid-connected homes, but LPG remains a solid option for those off the grid.
4. Environmental Impact: How Green Are They?
When it comes to the environment, both LPG and natural gas are cleaner than other fossil fuels like coal or oil. But there are some important differences:
- LPG emits fewer particulates and sulphur, making it a cleaner burning fuel. However, as a by-product of oil refining, it still releases significant carbon emissions.
- Natural Gas produces less CO₂ per unit of energy than LPG, and methane is a much cleaner burning fuel. But leaks during extraction or transportation can release methane, a potent greenhouse gas.
Verdict: Both gases are relatively clean, but natural gas has a slight edge for environmental impact, provided there are no leaks.
5. Safety: Which is Safer for Your Home?
Safety is a key concern when storing or using gas.
- LPG is heavier than air, meaning it can collect in low areas if there’s a leak, increasing the risk of explosion if it isn’t properly ventilated.
- Natural Gas, being lighter than air, will rise and disperse more quickly in case of a leak. That said, leaks in enclosed spaces can still pose a danger.
Both gases are generally safe with proper precautions, but natural gas has the advantage of being lighter and less likely to accumulate dangerously in low-lying areas.
Verdict: Natural gas is slightly safer due to its lighter weight, but both require proper handling and safety measures.
6. Applications: Where Can You Use LPG and Natural Gas?
Both LPG and natural gas have versatile uses, but certain applications suit one better than the other.
- LPG is commonly used in rural homes, caravans, boats, and outdoor settings where mains gas is unavailable. It’s also popular for BBQs, portable heaters, and industrial machinery.
- Natural Gas is widely used in homes for heating, cooking, and water heating, as well as in industrial settings and for power generation.
If you live off the grid or need portable gas, LPG is a great choice. If you’re connected to the mains, natural gas is usually the go-to option.
Verdict: LPG is perfect for off-grid and portable applications, while natural gas excels in homes with pipeline access.
Final Thoughts: Which is Right for You?
So, which should you choose—LPG or Natural Gas? Here’s a quick recap:
- Choose LPG if you live in a rural or off-grid area, need portable fuel, or require high-energy output for specific applications like outdoor heating.
- Choose Natural Gas if you’re connected to the gas grid and want a more affordable, convenient option with lower carbon emissions.
Both fuels have their pros and cons, but the best choice depends on your location, energy needs, and budget. Hopefully, this guide has helped clear up the differences and set you on the right path toward energy efficiency!
Calling All Gas Engineers: Become an LPG Expert with SERT
If you’re a gas engineer looking to expand your skillset, now is the perfect time to get certified in LPG! SERT’s LPG Training Course offers comprehensive, hands-on training to help you become an expert in LPG installation, maintenance, and safety.
Whether you're looking to service rural homes, caravans, or off-grid businesses, this course is designed to equip you with the knowledge and qualifications needed to excel in this growing market.
take the next step in your career by mastering LPG with SERT’s accredited training course. Don’t miss out on this opportunity to stand out in the gas engineering industry!
Ready to upskill and become an LPG specialist? Visit SERT’s LPG Training Course to learn more and enrol now!